From:    heb_roots_chr@mail.geocities.com
To:      "Hebraic Heritage Newsgroup"<heb_roots_chr@geocities.com>
Date:    Tue, 23 Dec 1997 03:08:14 +0000
Subject: December 25th as Yeshua Lord's birthday

 

From:          Alan Kowaleski
To:            heb_roots_chr@geocities.com
Subject:       December 25th as Yeshua Lord's birthday

I was wondering if anyone knows if there is a specific document or council
which decided on the Christmas date? Of course the earliest Christians would
not be found observing it. When in the history of the church did it become
official? Did early Christians oppose it. How easily did Babylonian
priestcraft infuse the church? Where were the fathers of apostolic succession
and the guiding Spirit of Ruach Hakodesh. 

I believe the Spirit guarded against the heresies which Paul spoke about in
his days,and brought  the Word of scripture to us intact down to present
times. I am hoping that the observence of Christmas was approved of by the
early church, however  my search for the historical truth has been
unrevealing to me.

Who can tell me of the correct references to search. Can someone recommend a
good text book? I would be grateful if anyone can help!

Your brother in Yeshua HaMaschiac,
Alan

>From Eddie:
*************

     While the Almighty God kept and preserved for us the integrity 
of His written Word (both OT and NT), the same cannot be said of our 
"Church Fathers" regarding some of the things that they have passed 
down to us and have become firmly planted tradition within the modern 
Christian church.  For example, many of the views held by traditional 
Christianity today toward the "law" and perceived as solid NT 
teaching by taking certain NT passages out of context began to take 
firm root in Christian doctrine over the many centuries through the 
influence of the teachings of Marcion. Marcion was considered a heritic 
by the church leaders in his day yet many of his views toward the 
law, the Jewish people and the OT are widely accepted within 
traditional Christianity today as being NT Biblical truths.

      You can read your Bible a zillion times and you will NEVER find 
Christmas celebrated in the NT. However, you can read Matthew, Mark, 
Luke, John and Acts and see the Biblical Festivals being celebrated.  
Christmas is something which began  to be celebrated after the days 
of Constantine when the Roman  Catholic church "Christianized" the 
beliefs of Mithraism. The birthday of the sun god in Mithraism was 
Dec 25th. When the Roman Empire gave up the religion of Mithraism 
because Constantine made Christianity the state religion and as the 
Roman Catholic church mixed and "Christianized" the practices of 
Mithraism and incorporated them into Christianity to make it more 
acceptable to the people who lived within the Roman Empire, the 
celebration of Christmas came into being. While the Word of God and 
it's integrity may have been preserved for us through the 
guiding hand of God, the same cannot be said of many of our Christian 
traditions. One of these traditions is Christmas. 

     I will give some information which comes from the Catholic 
Encyclopedia under the article of "Christmas". This is a good source 
to BEGIN your studies. Sometimes the Catholic church does  a good 
job of documenting how they brought some of the original pagan 
practices into Christianity.  Their documentation of the origin of 
Christmas and it's relationship to the birthday of the sun god in 
Mithraism is one example of many. Another thing that the Catholic 
church has done that they have documented quite well is how they  
changed the sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. But, this is 
another issue. The following section is taken from the Catholic 
Encyclopedia under the article of Christmas. You can get a copy of 
the Catholic Encyclopedia in most libraries across the USA.


                           THE HISTORY OF CHRISTMAS

      The feast is first mentioned at the head of the Depositio 
Martyum in the Roman Chronograph of 354 (ed. Valentini-Zucchetti) 
(Vatican City 1942) 2:17]. Since the Depositio was composed in 336, 
Christmas in Rome can be dated back that far at least. It is NOT 
(capitals mine) found, however, in the lists of feasts given by 
Tertulian (De baptismo 19; CSEL 20:217) and Origen (Contra Celsum 
8:22, PG 11:1549). (Tertulian and Origen were early Church Fathers 
... Eddie)

     Why then was December 25 (the date for Christ's birth as 
observed by the Western Roman Empire .... the Catholic church) and
January 6 (the date of Christ's birth as observed by the Eastern 
Roman Empire ... the Greek Orthodox Church) ??? (As you can see the 
Protestant world follows the date of the Roman Catholic Church and 
not the date of the Greek Orthodox Church ... Eddie). Several 
theories are offered in explanation.

       Some (John Chrysostom, B. Lamy: see Kellner, 143-145) actually 
believed December 25 was the birthday of Christ and tried to prove it 
by arguing from the conception of St. John the Baptist. Assuming, 
gratuitously, that Zachary was high priest and that the Day of 
Atonement fell on September 24, John would have been born on June 24 
and Christ 6 month's later, on December 25. This theory is now 
considered completely UNTENABLE (capitals mine ...  Do you 
see how twisted logic can become when this story is not understood 
from a Hebraic perspective? ... Eddie)

       According to the hypothesis suggested by H. Usener, developed 
by B. Botte (Les Origines) and accepted by most scholars today, the 
birth of Christ was assigned the date of the winter solstice 
(December 25 in the Julian Calander and January 6 in the Egyptian) 
because on this day, as the sun began its return to northern skies, 
the pagan devotees of Mithra celebrated the dies natalis Solis 
Invicti (birthday of the invincible sun). On December 25, 274, 
Aurelian had proclaimed the sun-god principal patron of the empire 
and dedicated a temple to him in Campus Martius. Christmas originated 
at a time when the cult of the sun was particularly strong in Rome.  
This theory finds support in some of the Church Fathers' contrasting 
the birth of Christ and the winter solstice; indeed, from the 
beginning of the 3rd century "Sun of Justice" appears as a title of 
Christ (Botte, Les origines 63).

          In the East (Eastern Roman Empire), the Feast of the 
Nativity (Christmas) was kept originally on January 6. Nevertheless, 
toward the end of the 4th century the Western feast of December 25 
was admitted. The earliest testimony to an Eastern Feast of Christmas 
is a sermon of Basil (d. 379; Homilia in s. Christi generationem, 
PG 31:1457-76). On December 25, 379 or 380, Gregory of Nazianzuz 
preached a Christmas sermon in Constantinople (In theophaniam 
oratio 38, PG 36:311-334); he later referred to himself as the founder of 
the feast (In sancta lumina oratio 39.14; PG 36:349). In Palestine, 
however, the birth of Christ was celebrated on January 6 until the 
middle of the 7th century when December 25th was permanently 
accepted. 

                                 **********************


    For further articles on this issue, please visit my Web Site 
located at:

    http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/2175/sab_fest.html

    So, the Catholic church through the Catholic Encyclopedia 
documents the pagan origin of Christmas and how it came to be 
celebrated.  The reasons have no Biblical basis. Through tradition, 
the Protest churches have continued to the practice of Christmas as 
originally given to us from the Catholic church. While the Protestant 
churches have rejected the authority of the Pope over the past 500 
years, they have not rejected everything within Christianity that has 
it's orgins in the Roman Catholic church. Think about this for a 
minute, the roots of Christianity are either in Rome or Jerusalem. The 
roots of Christianity are either Catholic or Jewish. Where do you 
think the roots of Christianity are?

***********************************************************************




    
1