Subject: National Unity Coalition in Support of Israel Date: Fri, 3 Apr 1998 00:25:10 +0000 To: "Hebraic Heritage Newsgroup"heb_roots_chr@geocities.com
To: (IL/ROOT & BRANCH ASSOCIATION, LTD.), rb@rb.org.il From: "Root & Branch Association, Ltd." <rbranch@netvision.net.il> Subject: R&B INFORMATION SERVICES: "In D.C. - Rallies and Clinton's War of Attrition" by Susan Rosenbluth R&B INFORMATION SERVICES: "In D.C. - Rallies and Clinton's War of Attrition" by Susan Rosenbluth WASHINGTON, D.C., April 2, 1998, Root & Branch: While waiting for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to show up at the Mayflower Hotel on Jan. 19, Michael Gress, pastor of the Lion of Judah Fellowship of Reston, Virginia, recalled a story Bill Clinton often told in 1992 while running for the Presidency: On his deathbed, Mr. Clinton's pastor told the then-young man, "If you ever become President, and you let Israel down, I will never forgive you." One of Pastor Gress' congregants held a sign declaring: You've let your pastor down, Mr. Clinton. Mr. Gress and his people were at the hotel to participate in a rally called by the National Unity Coalition for Israel (NUC). The NUC is an umbrella group consisting of some 200 pro-Israel Jewish and Christian organizations representing many Americans. Most of the Jewish organizations are right-wing, and most of the Christian groups are Evangelical. Although the group had only a week to plan the rally, it became evident early in the afternoon that more than double the number of people who would fit into the hotel's grand ballroom had shown up. While the American media portrayed the rally as consisting of Christian political enemies of the President, in fact, half the leaders and organizers of NUC are Jewish. Many of them Orthodox. Posters Standing near Mr. Gress, a member of another Christian delegation to the rally from Florida held up a poster which featured a big picture of Paula Jones. In a reference to Mr. Clinton's sexual scandals, the caption quoted a verse from the Bible: "Who curses Israel, I will curse." (Genesis 12:3) While several thousand people waited to get into the rally, several dozen Jewish protesters outside the hotel showed up with a live sheep and paraded around Connecticut Avenue proclaiming: "We will not go like sheep to the slaughter" and "The L-rd is Our Shepherd, not the US State Department." Some protesters carried placards showing a cartoon image of Messrs. Clinton and Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini ("Yasir Arafat"), both wearing Mr. el-Husseini's signature kaffiyeh. The caption read: "Two of a Kind: Yasir and Bill at Home in the White House." The State Department was reportedly furious with the cartoon, especially since it appeared as a full-page advertisement in both the Washington Times and the New York Post. Some members of the Conference of Presidents of Major American-Jewish Organizations, who were in the hotel for a later meeting with Mr. Netanyahu, blasted the cartoon, calling it racist. Across the street from the hotel, about a dozen protesters demonstrated against Mr. Netanyahu. Our Conviction Most of the Jews and Christians who showed up at the hotel were there to participate in the NUC rally. To a man (and woman), they made clear they believed the President was pressuring Israel to withdraw from land while not insisting that the PA live up to its commitments. Some of the literature distributed by the NUC bore an inscription referring to the as-yet unchanged PLO Charter which still calls for Israel's destruction: "Our Conviction or Their Covenant." "It is simply inexplicable that America would demand anything more of Israel when Arafat has not even tried to live up to his side of the bargain," said Esther Levens, president of NUC. Mrs. Levens, a Jewish activist from Kansas, said she and members of her coalition had come to Washington to tell Mr. Netanyahu that Mr. Clinton is out of step with the American people, that the vast majority of Americans support a strong and secure Jewish state, that the President is not holding all the cards on this issue, and that the Prime Minister does not have to concede. The President's attitude sends a clear signal to terrorists, she said: "You can bomb Jews in Jerusalem and all we will do is fore them to give you more land." No Congressmen The NUC rally was not without its own share of controversy. Although the program was not billed as an Israeli Embassy event, some of the organizers said the Embassy had asked them not to include Congressmen and Senators, who wanted to participate, on the roster of speakers. The NUC organizers said they believed the Embassy was acting on orders from the State Department. In fact, Mr. Netanyahu did meet privately with some Senators and Congressmen before his summit with Mr. Clinton. He reportedly thanked House Speaker Newt Gingrich for his support. During a speech in Hollywood for the entertainment community, Mr. Gingrich was asked his opinion of the Clinton administration's policy on Israel, including its criticism of Mr. Netanyahu for not moving faster in the peace process. Mr. Gingrich said, "For our government to treat Netanyahu as we are doing, is totally wrong. And for our government to treat Arafat as a moral equivalent to Netanyahu is totally wrong." Sen. Brownback Mr. Netanyahu also met with Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS), chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee on Middle East Affairs. Mr. Brownback was also highly critical of the recent pressure on Israel by the Clinton administration. "It is inappropriate for the US to be demanding that the democratically elected government of Israel take actions which undermine its security. The administration must stop pressuring Israel into ceding more land and making more concessions as long as the Palestinians don't carry through on their promise to provide security, their part of the bargain struck in Oslo," he said. Mr. Brownback was also outraged atf one administration official's comments that Mr. Netanyahu would be treated like the President of Bulgaria. Bulgarian President Stoianov will be offered a modest reception on Feb. 10. "It is outrageous that anyone in the administration would so characterize the Prime Minister of one of the US strongest allies in the world. Foreign policy should not be reduced to sound bites, and the administration should immediately retract this statement and offer Mr. Netanyahu and Mr. Stoianov an apology," said Mr. Brownback. Answered Prayers During the rally, Mrs. Levens praised the group for bringing together so many Christians and Jews united for a single purpose. "When Israel was embattled," she said, "the Jewish community often wondered where it could find friends. We prayed for guidance, and the L-rd sent us millions of American Christian people who love the Jewish people and Israel and have pledged to stand with us no matter what," she said. She insisted Mr. Clinton was listening to the wrong people and reading the wrong polls. "The American people," she said, "agreed more strongly with those in the Mayflower ballroom than they did with the advice offered by Sarah Ehrman, the President's liaison to the Jewish community and a Peace Now advocate. Recently, Ms. Ehrman said that Palestinian acts of terror were the inevitable response to acts of provocation, such as continued building in Jerusalem by the Israeli government." Mrs. Levens characterized Ms. Ehrman's remarks as justifying the murder of Jews. "We've heard that routine before," said Mrs. Levens, that the Jews brought it on themselves." Statistics Mrs. Levens pointed to statistics showing that by a margin of three-to-one, American Jews want Israel to be able to reach its own conclusions in negotiations with the Arabs rather than following orders from the US. By a margin of 73 percent to 23 percent, American Jews agreed with Mr. Netanyahu that terror must end before peace negotiations can continue. Calling the Oslo Process, land for nothing, Mrs. Levens said the Israeli in your face attitude was better than the Arabs behind your back. "That's where we believe Arafat has gone. He is using Israeli land and weapons to destroy the Jewish state," she said, adding that the PLO leader went behind America's back by telling the Moslem conference in Teheran, Iran, that the Israelis planned to desecrate and destroy the Al-Aksa Mosque. "He told that lie in Arabic, not in English," said Mrs. Levens. Agreeing with Mrs. Levens, Janet Parshall, a syndicated Christian radio talk-show host who served as the rally's Master of Ceremonies, declared that Mr. Clinton would hear the truth from Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini ("Arafat") only if he spoke to him in Arabic. Dr. E. Brandt Gustavson, President of the National Religious Broadcasters, reminded the audience that Israel and Jerusalem have had a love affair for 3,000 years. Even when Jews were swept away from their land, Jerusalem held the hearts of her children, he said, noting that Islamic faith-claims to the Holy City date back to the 7th century CE. "Jews occupied Jerusalem 1600 years before Islam saw the light of day," he said. Mort Klein Only the Prime Minister himself received greater applause from the crowd than did ZOA president Morton Klein. He characterized the Palestinian commitments to the Oslo process as a table with four legs. The PA, he said, has violated each of them: "The Palestinians were required to stop terror, but, instead, they have refused to extradite terrorists or confiscate illegal weapons, and every day in official PA newspapers and radio reports, there is incitement to terror; the PA was required to change the covenant which gave Israel no right to exist, but the PLO map shows only a map of Palestine which subsumes all of Israel; the PA was required to protect human rights, but there are still torture chambers in Jericho and Ramallah and those who sell land to Israel are imprisoned, tortured, and murdered; and they were required to eliminate official hate speech, but there are still daily calls for holy war and pronouncements that the intifada is our only option." "Hate speech against Jews and Israel is everywhere, on Palestinian radio, in their newspapers, and at their rallies," said Mr. Klein, noting that the constant calls for jihad came from Mr. Arafat as well as from the supposed fringe elements. "It was Arafat [Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini] who told Arabs in Hebron to have 12 children per family so they could give him 10 to destroy Israel," said Mr. Klein. In the Palestinian media, Jews are called stingy Shylocks who spill Arab blood and spike bubble gum sold to Arabs with the AIDS virus. Recently, the anti-American rhetoric, which has always been part of the Palestinian routine, has become ubiquitous. The Palestinians have made no secret of their support for Saddam Hussein against the US, which they define, along with Israel, as the enemy who has committed crimes against humanity. Many commentators on official PLO outlets equate the relationship of the US and Iraq to that between Israel and the PA. "Dont pressure your friend, Israel," Mr. Klein warned the President. "Pressure the enemy of peace, Arafat [Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini]." Transfer Recently, the ZOA initiated a campaign to insist that the PA transfer identified murderers of Americans to the US for trial. At the rally, Mr. Klein pointed out that, by a margin of four to one, Americans agree with this initiative. Further, he said, by the same margin, Americans believe Jerusalem should remain the undivided capital of Israel, and by a margin of six to one, Americans support Mr. Netanyahu over Mr. Arafat. He decried the State Department policy that seemed to say the administration is not interested in the hate spewing from the PA media or the fact that murderers of Americans are still at liberty in the Palestinian Autonomy. "If all Clinton cares about is Israel's unilateral withdrawal from Judea and Samaria, it means Clinton does not support Oslo," said Mr. Klein. Israeli Ambassador to the UN Dore Gold, who spoke after Mr. Klein, told the rally that Israel's most important dream was to achieve peace with safe, defensible borders and with Jerusalem as its capital. Nullifying the Accords "Because of the Palestinian violations of the agreements, upon his election, Mr. Netanyahu could have declared the Oslo process a fraud and brought it to a close," said Mr. Gold, or, alternatively, he could have behaved like the previous government and refused to blame the PLO for the terror even though it was clear they were involved. Instead, said Mr. Gold, Mr. Netanyahu chose to support the Israeli consensus. He decided to take an impaired peace process and make it work, said Mr. Gold, explaining the genesis of the government's doctrine of reciprocity, which, he said, is not a principle designed to help Israel escape from the Oslo process. Rather, he said, only reciprocity could make Oslo work. "If only one side complies and the other doesn't, the end can only be disaster," he said. Coupling Attempts by the Arabs to separate Israel from its natural ally, the US, fly in the face of the American cold war experience, he said. The US won the cold war through strength, overcoming the attempts by the former Soviet Union to separate America from her NATO allies, a process Mr. Gold called de-coupling. To assure peace in the Middle East, make sure Israel and the US remain coupled, he told participants at the rally, adding that those who believe distancing the US from Israel will result in moving the peace process further, are wrong. Peace can be achieved only by a close US-Israel relationship, in which the enemies of peace are distanced, he said. Although Evangelical leader Jerry Falwell was not scheduled to address the rally, he was spotted by Mrs. Levens who invited him to come to the microphone. Calling himself a minister and supporter of Israel for 45 years, he characterized the foreign aid given to Israel as the best national security investment the US makes in the world. Citing the Biblical passage that G-d will bless those who bless Israel and curse those who curse her, Mr. Falwell said he believed the US has been blessed in proportion to how much we bless Israel. Standing Ovation Just as Rev. Falwell was noting that those present represented 70 million Christians and a few less Jews who were brought together by issues larger than each group alone, the Prime Minister, his wife, Sara, and the Israeli contingent walked onto the platform. Mr. Netanyahu received a sustained five-minute standing ovation from the crowd and hugs and warm handshakes from speakers on the dais. Relinquishing the microphone, Mr. Falwell said he loved Israel because he loved freedom and democracy, and he paid Mr. Netanyahu the highest complement he could think of. "You're the Ronald Reagan of Israel," he told the Prime Minister, and the crowd, who obviously agreed, applauded all over again. Fatigued and more than a little hoarse, Mr. Netanyahu said it was worth traveling 12 hours for that ovation. While he thanked everyone on the dais, he singled out Mr. Klein for his heart-warming friendship and support. Christian Zionists As they had all afternoon, the crowd erupted with applause every time Mr. Netanyahu evoked Jerusalem, which, he said, would never be divided again. The Prime Minister recalled the idealism and faith of 19th-century Christian Zionists who, he said, created the groundwork for Jewish Zionists. "The Christian Zionists came to the holy land with the desire to see it brought back to life by the one people who could do it, the Jews," he said. Insisting that would achieve a just peace, Mr. Netanyahu decried the depiction of Israel by the Palestinians and their supporters in the media as usurpers of the land and practitioners of Nazi ideology. "That's how we're vilified daily," he said, noting that when Israel is cast as the villain of the Middle East, it does great violence to truth and justice. The Charter Explaining his position on reciprocity, he said, "We can't be asked to sign the next agreement when the last agreement has been violated so systematically. The Palestinian Charter calling for the destruction of the State of Israel can be annulled only by convening the Palestinian National Congress who must then formally go through the motions of tearing up the document," he said. "It is a legal demand, but also a moral demand," said Mr. Netanyahu. "How can there be peace when one of the parties has on its books a contract calling for the other's destruction?" Mr. Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini's ("Arafat's") letters saying that the charter has been amended is insufficient, he said. "They must tear up the document publicly, in front of the world, and then well know they did something," he said, noting that it has been four years since the PA promised to annul their charter. "It's about time," said Mr. Netanyahu. He also listed other Palestinian commitments which have not been fulfilled, including fighting terror and extraditing wanted terrorists to Israel for trial. Hard To Comply Mr. Netanyahu said he understood how hard it was to keep agreements, because he had felt anguish in relinquishing 80 percent of Hebron, "It was tough for me to do it, but I did it because I keep agreements. They dont," he said. "Every grain of soil is saturated with the tears and blood of generations of Jewish people." He stressed that the claim that both parties to the Oslo process are not in compliance is false. We are in compliance, and in exchange for Palestinian compliance, we would be prepared to consider withdrawing from those less crucially strategic territories, he said, adding that he would not jeopardize the security of Israel. "We don't want a photo-op peace, but a peace for now and for generations," he said. As he and his contingent left the platform, Jews and Christians joined together holding a banner with a Star of David chanting, "Not one inch." Terror Victims Two family members of Arab-terror victims were part of Mr. Netanyahu's contingent: Yehudit Shachor, 44, whose son, Ori, and his friend, Ehud Bachrach, were killed by terrorists as they hiked in Wadi Kelt on July 19, 1995; and Sigal Megidish, 27, whose brother, Uri, was murdered in Wadi Kelt in 1993, after the accords were signed. The terrorists responsible for the murder of Mr. Shachor are living freely in Jericho, having been released from a PA prison after serving one day. Mr. Megidish's killers are members of the PA police force in Gaza. Repeated extradition requests for the men submitted to the PA Ministry of Justice by Israel have been ignored. In the hallway of the Mayflower, Mrs. Shachor and Ms. Megidish took a minute to rest in between the NUC rally and the up-coming meeting with the Conference of Presidents. "Our purpose in coming is to ask the American administration by what right are they, who are so zealous in seeking killers of their citizens so long as they are not in Israel, so anxious for us to concede on this issue. The killers of our children roam freely within a few kilometers of our homes, and the Americans press us to forget this and withdraw from more territory?" said Mrs. Shachor. She noted that Mr. Netanyahu happily agreed to have her join him on the trip. This was in contrast, she said, to her experience with former Prime Minister Shimon Peres, with whom she met when he was about to sign another agreement with Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini ("Arafat"). According to Mrs. Shachor, Mr. Peres told her, "Look, I am here to sign a peace agreement with Arafat [Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini]. I can't help you. Arafat [el-Husseini] is here. Why dont you speak with him about your son?" Bounced Check While members of the Conference of Presidents lined up to be admitted to a meeting room a few doors down from rally, Chuck Jacobs, one of NUCs organizers, was telling the Christians and Jews still in their seats that the real estate deal signed on the White House lawn was paid for by a check certified by the US. "The PA got Gaza and Jericho first and more redeployment and Hebron, but all Israel got was a bounced check," he said. Less than an hour after he addressed the NUC rally, Mr. Netanyahu and his contingent were ready to take on the Conference of Presidents. "There won't be any standing ovations here," said one machor as he passed through the metal detectors and security. He was wrong. The Prime Minister did receive a standing ovation when he entered the room, but it lacked endurance and enthusiasm. In general, the Jewish leaders were prepared for business. Meeting with Clinton At the start of the meeting, Mel Salberg, chairman of the Conference of Presidents, discussed advertisements and letters undertaken by the umbrella organization in support of Mr. Netanyahu and his position. Earlier that morning, he said, he and Malcolm Hoenlein, executive vice president of the Conference, had met with Mr. Clinton to discuss what Mr. Salberg called the shift in the government's attitude. According to Mr. Salberg, Mr. Clinton said he was still totally committed to the peace process and supported the concept of compliance. "He said his support for Israel was unshakable and that the special relationship between the US and Israel was as strong as ever," said Mr. Salberg, adding that the government was still committed to preserving Israels military qualitative edge. In addition, said Mr. Salberg, the President indicated he felt positive about the up-coming meetings with Messrs. Netanyahu and Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini [Arafat], and that he and the Secretary of State enjoyed working with the Prime Minister. In an Arutz-7 interview, Mr. Hoenlein said, "While the President wants to move the process forward, he understands that pressure is not the way to do that." David Bar-Illan Addressing the Conference before the Prime Minister entered the room, government spokesman David Bar-Illan said Mr. Netanyahu's doctrine of reciprocity had injected new life into the peace process. "The same 75 percent of the Knesset and the population that accepted the withdrawal from Hebron last year now insists on one of the joint pillars of the agreement - reciprocity," he said. Commenting on Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini's ("Arafat's") declarations that the PLO Charter has already been amended, Mr. Bar-Illan said that two weeks before coming to the US, the Israeli government asked for a copy of the charter. "We received the old covenant without a single word changed," he said, adding that, "in Hebrew, there were even the same old spelling mistakes." "The average Palestinian knows nothing has been changed," said Mr. Bar-Illan. Revolving Door Justice He noted the press reports crediting the PA with finding a bomb factory in Nablus. "The PA police did nothing to deter the factory's operation, until Israel demanded its termination, and then some people were arrested," he said. The factory, which was known to everyone in Nablus, he said, could easily have been discovered much earlier, had the PA police been motivated to stop terror. Earlier in the week, he said, the PA announced the arrest of two Hamas members who, they said, were responsible for last summers bombings in Jerusalem. After a quickie trial, they were sentenced to 15 years in prison. "Its anybody's bet if they stay in jail for two weeks," said Mr. Bar-Illan. "If the previous pattern is followed, they wont stay much longer." Asked why Israel had not closed down Orient House, Mr. Bar-Illan said the government had stopped the PA's foreign affairs activities in the house, which is privately owned by Faisal al-Husseini. Truth Matters During his brief talk with members of the Conference, Mr. Netanyahu once again explained his doctrine of reciprocity. For the next treaty to have meaning, the previous treaty must have meaning, he said. Explaining that truth matters, he said the commitments made but not kept by the PA are simple and verifiable. "If they dont fight terror and keep the promises they made, there will be no peace," he said. Once again, he said that Israel would have to insist on secure borders because an Israel that cant defend itself will not be able to live in peace. Still a Dangerous Neighborhood "Rather than pretending Israel is part of Western Europe or North America, Israel understands that, for peace to have a chance, the Jewish state must be able to deter attacks from the East and the West," he said. This necessitates buffer zones as well as ways to prevent the entry of terrorists. He admitted the plan is neither ideal nor completely satisfactory to his military advisers, but it is a minimum requirement. "We have a finite amount of area we can cede in exchange for Palestinian compliance," he said, adding he would prefer to move directly to final status negotiations. "The amount of land Israel is willing to cede will allow the Palestinians to govern themselves," he said, "while reserving for the Jewish state the ability to defend itself." "I wont jeopardize Israel's security," he said, prompting the members of the Conference to applaud. "I'll agree to discuss that territory that is so hard to part from, because it resonates with our history. Every grain of earth speaks to me. But I'm prepared painfully to part from the land, provided it doesn't jeopardize our security," he said. No Contradiction Asked by Rabbi Fabian Schoenfeld to explain the seeming contradiction that, on one hand, the map prepared by Defense Minister Yitzhak Mordechai implied he was willing to abandon the community of Beit El, but, a few days later, it was announced that a new neighborhood would be built in the community. According to Mr. Netanyahu, the Defense Minister never spoke of dismantling Beit El. His map, said the Prime Minister, delineated military security zones as well as areas of national interest, such as those sitting on top of aquifers which must be preserved in order to assure citizens on the coast their drinking water. He then denied that Israel was building new settlements, but it is allowing for natural growth, which is determined by births, marriages, and relocations. "We don't direct people to the settlements," he said, admitting there are subsidies to all Israelis who move to development towns on both sides of the Green Line. With the cost of housing along the coast increasing, many young couples are moving elsewhere, he said. Palestinian Building Further, he said, despite Palestinian claims that new homes in Judea, Samaria, and Jerusalem violate the Oslo Agreement, the fact is, such building is not even addressed by the Accords. "Yitzhak Rabin stood before the Knesset after he signed the agreement and said proudly that Oslo precluded neither expanding existing settlements nor building new ones. We're not building new ones," he said. The Palestinians, on the other hand, are building illegally in areas in which Oslo specifically denies them permission to do so, he said. "Israel won't unilaterally agree to curtail our communities while the Palestinians build theirs," he said. The total built-up area used by the Israelis amounts to just one percent of Judea and Samaria, he said, and the new building about which the Palestinians are complaining, amounts to just one-tenth of one percent. "This is the creation of facts on the ground?" he said. "Only in people's minds. Yes, perception is reality, but reality is also reality." Threats He dismissed the Palestinian threat to re-initiate the intifada or unilaterally to declare a Palestinian State if Mr. Clinton fails to force the Israelis to withdraw from 30 percent of YESHA immediately. "Threats of violence should be condemned because there is no room in the peace process for the attitude that says if we don't get Israel to accede to our demands, well try to coerce them with violence," he said. "If every time we disagree, the Palestinians brandish the sword of terror, then there is no peace process at all," he said. Withdrawing from 30 percent in each redeployment would leave Israel nothing to discuss in the final settlement, he said. We must reject that in principle and in theory, and hope the US adopts that attitude, too, he said, adding that if the Palestinians engage in unilateral actions, then Israel will, too. Asked if the US should pressure both sides equally, Mr. Netanyahu said, on the issue of compliance, that would be impossible, because there is no symmetry. Israel, he said, was already in compliance, while the PA is not. He said he would prefer the word encourage. "The US should encourage both sides to exchange views," he said. "If the Palestinians believe terror or US pressure will force our hand, they are wrong," he said, adding that only when Abdul Rauf el-Codba el-Husseini ("Arafat") realizes he must negotiate with Israel for a permanent settlement will there be real progress. "The US is in an exceptional position to encourage the PA to accept that message," he said. >From the Conference of Presidents, the Prime Minister and his party walked across the hall to yet another room in the Mayflower Hotel, where a room full of mostly Jewish guests who had been invited by the Israeli Embassy were waiting to hear the Prime Minister deliver the same message. Again, he was received well, but the reception could not hold a candle to the enthusiasm displayed by the NUC participants.